Several nights ago, I heard Rachel Goldberg-Polin and Jon Polin speak about their son Hersh Goldberg-Polin who was kidnapped by Hamas terrorists during the October 7, 2023, attacks on Israel. For nearly eleven months, his parents became international advocates for his release and for the release of other hostages. Their tireless efforts, dignity, and humanity inspired people around the world. Tragically, Hersh was murdered in captivity in August 2024.
Their story is one of extraordinary love, courage, determination, and unimaginable heartbreak.
Rachel and Jon were originally from Chicago and moved to Jerusalem in 2008 with their three children. Hersh, their only son, was attending the music festival in southern Israel, when Hamas attacked and took him prisoner.
After Hersh was captured, Rachel and Jon met with world leaders, including President Joe Biden and Pope Francis, to address the United Nations, participate in demonstrations and appeal to the international community. Their message was simple: innocent people should not be held hostage and every effort should be made to bring them home.
Rachel described to the audience that she wore a piece of masking tape on her clothing displaying the number of days Hersh had been held captive. This small gesture became a powerful symbol of the passage of time and suffering endured by hostage families.
I was struck by the composure of Rachel and Jon, who spoke with remarkable composure about their anguish. Both said that to have solace revenge was not an answer. They recognized that Israeli and Palestinian families were experiencing terrible losses and that innocent lives deserved protection, irrespective of nationality. They expressed hope that Hersh’s death might become a turning point and help prevent further tragedies. Unfortunately, I do not share their optimism.
The legacy of Rachel Goldberg-Polin and Jon Polin extends beyond their son’s tragic death. Specifically, their story reminds us that behind every hostage is a family whose life has been shattered. Their dignity and compassion are an inspiration even in the darkest circumstances.
On a personal note, I will never understand October 7. That is, it unleashed suffering for both Israelis and Palestinians. To paraphrase a quote from Psalm 34:18, “your suffering is real, but it is not the end of your story. There is hope beyond what you are going through right now.”
Doc welcomes your constructive comments and perspectives at ernestwerlin@gmail.com.

